P.0
6
Resurrecting the Sublime

Resurrecting the Sublime

Could we ever again smell flowers driven to extinction by humans?

Resurrecting the Sublime

Could we ever again smell flowers driven to extinction by humans?

Resurrecting the Sublime

Could we ever again smell flowers driven to extinction by humans?

Resurrecting the Sublime

Could we ever again smell flowers driven to extinction by humans?

This question motivates Resurrecting the Sublime, an ongoing collaboration between artist Dr. Alexandra Daisy Ginsberg, smell researcher and artist Sissel Tolaas, and an interdisciplinary team of researchers and engineers from the biotechnology company Ginkgo Bioworks, led by Creative Director Dr. Christina Agapakis, with the support of IFF Inc. In a series of immersive installations, the first in the exhibition La Fabrique du Vivant at the Centre Pompidou in Paris (opening 18 February 2019), the project allows us to smell extinct flowers, lost due to colonial activity.
This question motivates Resurrecting the Sublime, an ongoing collaboration between artist Dr. Alexandra Daisy Ginsberg, smell researcher and artist Sissel Tolaas, and an interdisciplinary team of researchers and engineers from the biotechnology company Ginkgo Bioworks, led by Creative Director Dr. Christina Agapakis, with the support of IFF Inc. In a series of immersive installations, the first in the exhibition La Fabrique du Vivant at the Centre Pompidou in Paris (opening 18 February 2019), the project allows us to smell extinct flowers, lost due to colonial activity.
This question motivates Resurrecting the Sublime, an ongoing collaboration between artist Dr. Alexandra Daisy Ginsberg, smell researcher and artist Sissel Tolaas, and an interdisciplinary team of researchers and engineers from the biotechnology company Ginkgo Bioworks, led by Creative Director Dr. Christina Agapakis, with the support of IFF Inc. In a series of immersive installations, the first in the exhibition La Fabrique du Vivant at the Centre Pompidou in Paris (opening 18 February 2019), the project allows us to smell extinct flowers, lost due to colonial activity.
Rendering of a Hibiscadelphus wilderianus, an indigenous to ancient lava fields on the southern slopes of Mount Haleakalā, on Maui, Hawaii.

Using tiny amounts of DNA extracted from specimens of three flowers stored at Harvard University’s Herbaria, the Ginkgo team used synthetic biology to predict and resynthesize gene sequences that might encode for fragrance-producing enzymes. Using Ginkgo’s findings, Sissel Tolaas used her expertise to reconstruct the flowers’ smells in her lab, using identical or comparative smell molecules.

The Hibiscadelphus wilderianus Rock, or Maui hau kuahiwi in Hawaiian, was indigenous to ancient lava fields on the southern slopes of Mount Haleakalā, on Maui, Hawaii. Its forest habitat was decimated by colonial cattle ranching, and the final tree was found dying in 1912. The Orbexilum stipulatum, or Falls-of-the-Ohio Scurfpea, was last seen in 1881 on Rock Island in the Ohio River, near Louisville, Kentucky, before US Dam No. 41 finally flooded its habitat in the 1920s. The ‘Leucadendron grandiflorum (Salisb.) R. Br.’, the Wynberg Conebush has a more complex story, which we are still uncovering. It was last described in London in a collector’s garden in 1805; its habitat on Wynberg Hill, in the shadow of Table Mountain, Cape Town, South Africa, was already lost to colonial vineyards. This flower may prove to be completely lost: the project is bringing to light that specimens around the world may historically have been incorrectly identified.

While we can use technology to reach back into the past and learn which smell molecules the flowers may have produced, the amounts of each are also lost. In installations designed by Alexandra Daisy Ginsberg, fragments of each flower’s smell diffuse and mix, introducing contingency: there is no exact smell. The lost landscape is reduced to its geology and the flower’s smell: the human connects the two, and in contrast to a natural history museum, the human becomes the specimen on view.

Using genetic engineering to resurrect the smell of extinct flowers—so that humans may again experience something we have destroyed—is awesome and perhaps terrifying. This dizzying feeling evokes the sublime, an “expression of the unknowable”, an aesthetic state encouraging contemplation of humans’ position amidst the immensity of nature.

This is not de-extinction. Instead, biotechnology, smell, and reconstructed landscapes allow us to once again experience a flower blooming on a forested volcanic slope, in the shadow of a mountain, or on a wild river bank, revealing the interplay of species and places that no longer exist. Resurrecting the Sublime asks us to contemplate our actions, and potentially change them for the future.

Using tiny amounts of DNA extracted from specimens of three flowers stored at Harvard University’s Herbaria, the Ginkgo team used synthetic biology to predict and resynthesize gene sequences that might encode for fragrance-producing enzymes. Using Ginkgo’s findings, Sissel Tolaas used her expertise to reconstruct the flowers’ smells in her lab, using identical or comparative smell molecules.

The Hibiscadelphus wilderianus Rock, or Maui hau kuahiwi in Hawaiian, was indigenous to ancient lava fields on the southern slopes of Mount Haleakalā, on Maui, Hawaii. Its forest habitat was decimated by colonial cattle ranching, and the final tree was found dying in 1912. The Orbexilum stipulatum, or Falls-of-the-Ohio Scurfpea, was last seen in 1881 on Rock Island in the Ohio River, near Louisville, Kentucky, before US Dam No. 41 finally flooded its habitat in the 1920s. The ‘Leucadendron grandiflorum (Salisb.) R. Br.’, the Wynberg Conebush has a more complex story, which we are still uncovering. It was last described in London in a collector’s garden in 1805; its habitat on Wynberg Hill, in the shadow of Table Mountain, Cape Town, South Africa, was already lost to colonial vineyards. This flower may prove to be completely lost: the project is bringing to light that specimens around the world may historically have been incorrectly identified.

While we can use technology to reach back into the past and learn which smell molecules the flowers may have produced, the amounts of each are also lost. In installations designed by Alexandra Daisy Ginsberg, fragments of each flower’s smell diffuse and mix, introducing contingency: there is no exact smell. The lost landscape is reduced to its geology and the flower’s smell: the human connects the two, and in contrast to a natural history museum, the human becomes the specimen on view.

Using genetic engineering to resurrect the smell of extinct flowers—so that humans may again experience something we have destroyed—is awesome and perhaps terrifying. This dizzying feeling evokes the sublime, an “expression of the unknowable”, an aesthetic state encouraging contemplation of humans’ position amidst the immensity of nature.

This is not de-extinction. Instead, biotechnology, smell, and reconstructed landscapes allow us to once again experience a flower blooming on a forested volcanic slope, in the shadow of a mountain, or on a wild river bank, revealing the interplay of species and places that no longer exist. Resurrecting the Sublime asks us to contemplate our actions, and potentially change them for the future.

Using tiny amounts of DNA extracted from specimens of three flowers stored at Harvard University’s Herbaria, the Ginkgo team used synthetic biology to predict and resynthesize gene sequences that might encode for fragrance-producing enzymes. Using Ginkgo’s findings, Sissel Tolaas used her expertise to reconstruct the flowers’ smells in her lab, using identical or comparative smell molecules.

The Hibiscadelphus wilderianus Rock, or Maui hau kuahiwi in Hawaiian, was indigenous to ancient lava fields on the southern slopes of Mount Haleakalā, on Maui, Hawaii. Its forest habitat was decimated by colonial cattle ranching, and the final tree was found dying in 1912. The Orbexilum stipulatum, or Falls-of-the-Ohio Scurfpea, was last seen in 1881 on Rock Island in the Ohio River, near Louisville, Kentucky, before US Dam No. 41 finally flooded its habitat in the 1920s. The ‘Leucadendron grandiflorum (Salisb.) R. Br.’, the Wynberg Conebush has a more complex story, which we are still uncovering. It was last described in London in a collector’s garden in 1805; its habitat on Wynberg Hill, in the shadow of Table Mountain, Cape Town, South Africa, was already lost to colonial vineyards. This flower may prove to be completely lost: the project is bringing to light that specimens around the world may historically have been incorrectly identified.

While we can use technology to reach back into the past and learn which smell molecules the flowers may have produced, the amounts of each are also lost. In installations designed by Alexandra Daisy Ginsberg, fragments of each flower’s smell diffuse and mix, introducing contingency: there is no exact smell. The lost landscape is reduced to its geology and the flower’s smell: the human connects the two, and in contrast to a natural history museum, the human becomes the specimen on view.

Using genetic engineering to resurrect the smell of extinct flowers—so that humans may again experience something we have destroyed—is awesome and perhaps terrifying. This dizzying feeling evokes the sublime, an “expression of the unknowable”, an aesthetic state encouraging contemplation of humans’ position amidst the immensity of nature.

This is not de-extinction. Instead, biotechnology, smell, and reconstructed landscapes allow us to once again experience a flower blooming on a forested volcanic slope, in the shadow of a mountain, or on a wild river bank, revealing the interplay of species and places that no longer exist. Resurrecting the Sublime asks us to contemplate our actions, and potentially change them for the future.

Hands holding a plant pressing specimen.
I.01
Plant pressing from the Harvard Herbarium
Hands holding a plant pressing specimen.

Dried specimen of Hibiscadelphus wilderianus Rock, collected by Gerrit P. Wilder on Maui Island, Hawaii in 1910. Courtesy Gray Herbarium of Harvard University.

Dried specimen of Hibiscadelphus wilderianus Rock, collected by Gerrit P. Wilder on Maui Island, Hawaii in 1910. Courtesy Gray Herbarium of Harvard University.

Digital reconstruction of the extinct Hibiscadelphus wilderianus Rock on the southern slopes of Mount Haleakalā, Maui, Hawaii, around the time of its last sighting in 1912.
I.02
Hibiscadelphus wilderianus
Digital reconstruction of the extinct Hibiscadelphus wilderianus Rock on the southern slopes of Mount Haleakalā, Maui, Hawaii, around the time of its last sighting in 1912.

Digital reconstruction of the extinct Hibiscadelphus wilderianus Rock on the southern slopes of Mount Haleakalā, Maui, Hawaii, around the time of its last sighting in 1912.

Digital reconstruction of the extinct Hibiscadelphus wilderianus Rock on the southern slopes of Mount Haleakalā, Maui, Hawaii, around the time of its last sighting in 1912.

Off-angle view of a large cement warehouse-like room containing two parallel vitrines with smell diffusion, lava and limestone boulders, animations, and ambient soundscape.
I.03
Resurrecting the Sublime installation vitrines
Off-angle view of a large cement warehouse-like room containing two parallel vitrines with smell diffusion, lava and limestone boulders, animations, and ambient soundscape.

A group of students experience the extinct flower scents from inside the vitrines with smell diffusion.

A group of students experience the extinct flower scents from inside the vitrines with smell diffusion.

A large cement warehouse-like room containing two parallel vitrines with smell diffusion, lava and limestone boulders, animations, and ambient soundscape.
I.04
Biennale Internationale Design Saint-Étienne installation
A large cement warehouse-like room containing two parallel vitrines with smell diffusion, lava and limestone boulders, animations, and ambient soundscape.

Vitrines with smell diffusion, lava and limestone boulders, animations, and ambient soundscape. Left: Hibiscadelphus wilderianus Rock. Right: Orbexilum stipulatum. Installation view, Biennale Internationale Design Saint-Étienne, March 2019. Photograph: Pierre Grasset.

Vitrines with smell diffusion, lava and limestone boulders, animations, and ambient soundscape. Left: Hibiscadelphus wilderianus Rock. Right: Orbexilum stipulatum. Installation view, Biennale Internationale Design Saint-Étienne, March 2019. Photograph: Pierre Grasset.

Additional information

S.05

Additional information

S.01

Additional information

S.01

Extinction is forever. Or is it? Driven by a desire to remember the past and imagine the future, Resurrecting the Sublime is a captivating quest to recreate the scents of flowers made extinct by humans. A wild adventure in science and art, it inspires us to wonder anew about the magic of nature and our place in it.

Scents of the Past
Smell a flower and you inhale its very being, a magical moment conjured by a chemical reaction. Ginkgo Bioworks has discovered that while a flower may expire, its scent can live on. The quest began at Harvard University Herbarium, where scientists snipped samples from specimens of extinct flowers and used biotechnology to decode their DNA.

Solving the Puzzle
The DNA sequences only told part of the story, like fragmented pages salvaged from an ancient tome. So Ginkgo’s scientists turned to genetic engineering to reassemble the sequences and rewrite scent genes lost over 100 years ago. They printed the DNA and inserted the genes into yeast, giving life to the scents once more.

The Resurrection
A flower’s fragrance is not a single smell, it is a combination of chemicals, an alchemy of scents. To resurrect these fragrances in their wondrous complexity required a master of art and science. Sissel Tolaas, a smell researcher, expertly blended the smell molecules to reimagine the fragrance the flowers once had.

A Sublime Experience
The resurrection was nearly complete, but what is a fragrance with no one to smell it? An immersive installation by the artist Alexandra Daisy Ginsberg invites us to encounter the nature we have lost. This sensory experience inspires wonder and awe—a space to contemplate our place, a moment to encounter the sublime.

Watch the project video on Vimeo here. More information at resurrectingthesublime.com.

Extinction is forever. Or is it? Driven by a desire to remember the past and imagine the future, Resurrecting the Sublime is a captivating quest to recreate the scents of flowers made extinct by humans. A wild adventure in science and art, it inspires us to wonder anew about the magic of nature and our place in it.

Scents of the Past
Smell a flower and you inhale its very being, a magical moment conjured by a chemical reaction. Ginkgo Bioworks has discovered that while a flower may expire, its scent can live on. The quest began at Harvard University Herbarium, where scientists snipped samples from specimens of extinct flowers and used biotechnology to decode their DNA.

Solving the Puzzle
The DNA sequences only told part of the story, like fragmented pages salvaged from an ancient tome. So Ginkgo’s scientists turned to genetic engineering to reassemble the sequences and rewrite scent genes lost over 100 years ago. They printed the DNA and inserted the genes into yeast, giving life to the scents once more.

The Resurrection
A flower’s fragrance is not a single smell, it is a combination of chemicals, an alchemy of scents. To resurrect these fragrances in their wondrous complexity required a master of art and science. Sissel Tolaas, a smell researcher, expertly blended the smell molecules to reimagine the fragrance the flowers once had.

A Sublime Experience
The resurrection was nearly complete, but what is a fragrance with no one to smell it? An immersive installation by the artist Alexandra Daisy Ginsberg invites us to encounter the nature we have lost. This sensory experience inspires wonder and awe—a space to contemplate our place, a moment to encounter the sublime.

Watch the project video on Vimeo here. More information at resurrectingthesublime.com.

Project credits

S.06

Project Credits

S.02

Project Credits

S.02

Produced by Ginkgo Bioworks in partnership with Alexandra Daisy Ginsberg and Sissel Tolaas. The Ginkgo Bioworks team included Dr. Christina Agapakis, Natsai Audrey Chieza, Grace Chuang, Jason Kakoyiannis, Dr. Jason Kelly, Scott Marr, Krishna Patel, Kit McDonnell, Dr. Christian Ridley, Dr. Dayal Saran, Atsede Siba, Dr. Dawn Thompson, and Dr. Jue Wang. The Alexandra Daisy Ginsberg team includes Dr. Alexandra Daisy Ginsberg, Ana Maria Nicolaescu, Johanna Just, Ness Lafoy, Ioana Man, Stacie Woolsey, Nicholas Zembashi, and Cecilie Gravesen. Supported by IFF Inc., Vitrine Edition 1/3 with support from Therme Art Programe and MU Hybrid Art House. Vitrine Edition fabrication by: Tom Cecil Ltd. The Flowers: Hibiscadelphus wilderianus, coll. J. F. Rock s.n. from e [east] Maui, Hawaii. The Herbarium of the Arnold Arboretum of Harvard University; ‘Leucadendron grandiflorum (Salisb.) R. Br.’, coll. F.G. Meyer and T. R. Dudley s.n., Aug. 15- 20, 1966. The Herbarium of the Arnold Arboretum of Harvard University; Orbexilum stipulatum, coll. C. W. Short, Kentucky and Bot. Garden 1871. Gray Herbarium of Harvard University Paleogenomics by Dr. Joshua Kapp and Dr Beth Shapiro, Paleogenomics Lab, University of California, Santa Cruz; DNA synthesis by Twist Bioscience. Film editing by Inferstudio; Sound design by Sam Conran. Smell diffusion technology by Scentcommunication; Smell hood fabrication by Factory Settings. Special thanks to Dr. Michaela Schmull, Harvard University Herbaria, Cambridge. Special thank for plant research to Dr. Nicholas Hind, Dr. Gerhard Prenner, Harry Smith, The Herbarium, Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew; Dr. Anthony Roberts, Changing Lives Through Nature, Cape Town; Dr. Tony Rebelo, SANBI, Cape Town. Venice producer: Kat Pollman.

Produced by Ginkgo Bioworks in partnership with Alexandra Daisy Ginsberg and Sissel Tolaas. The Ginkgo Bioworks team included Dr. Christina Agapakis, Natsai Audrey Chieza, Grace Chuang, Jason Kakoyiannis, Dr. Jason Kelly, Scott Marr, Krishna Patel, Kit McDonnell, Dr. Christian Ridley, Dr. Dayal Saran, Atsede Siba, Dr. Dawn Thompson, and Dr. Jue Wang. The Alexandra Daisy Ginsberg team includes Dr. Alexandra Daisy Ginsberg, Ana Maria Nicolaescu, Johanna Just, Ness Lafoy, Ioana Man, Stacie Woolsey, Nicholas Zembashi, and Cecilie Gravesen. Supported by IFF Inc., Vitrine Edition 1/3 with support from Therme Art Programe and MU Hybrid Art House. Vitrine Edition fabrication by: Tom Cecil Ltd. The Flowers: Hibiscadelphus wilderianus, coll. J. F. Rock s.n. from e [east] Maui, Hawaii. The Herbarium of the Arnold Arboretum of Harvard University; ‘Leucadendron grandiflorum (Salisb.) R. Br.’, coll. F.G. Meyer and T. R. Dudley s.n., Aug. 15- 20, 1966. The Herbarium of the Arnold Arboretum of Harvard University; Orbexilum stipulatum, coll. C. W. Short, Kentucky and Bot. Garden 1871. Gray Herbarium of Harvard University Paleogenomics by Dr. Joshua Kapp and Dr Beth Shapiro, Paleogenomics Lab, University of California, Santa Cruz; DNA synthesis by Twist Bioscience. Film editing by Inferstudio; Sound design by Sam Conran. Smell diffusion technology by Scentcommunication; Smell hood fabrication by Factory Settings. Special thanks to Dr. Michaela Schmull, Harvard University Herbaria, Cambridge. Special thank for plant research to Dr. Nicholas Hind, Dr. Gerhard Prenner, Harry Smith, The Herbarium, Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew; Dr. Anthony Roberts, Changing Lives Through Nature, Cape Town; Dr. Tony Rebelo, SANBI, Cape Town. Venice producer: Kat Pollman.